The Sin of the Golden Calf and the Broken Tablets
While Moses is on the mountain the people cast a golden calf; coming down, he shatters the tablets, and the seventeenth of Tammuz becomes a fast for all generations.
Moses went up for forty days. The people, who had just heard a voice from heaven, miscounted the days and concluded their leader was gone. They surrounded Aaron: make us a god to go before us, for this man Moses, who brought us up, we do not know what became of him. In the Torah's telling Aaron played for time, asking for the gold earrings of their wives and children in the hope that collecting them would take days. The gold arrived at once. A molten calf came out of it, and a festival was declared. God told Moses to go down, and offered to destroy the people and make a nation from him instead. Moses refused and argued on their behalf. He came down with the two tablets, saw the calf and the dancing, and shattered them at the foot of the mountain. He burned the calf, ground it to powder and made the people drink it. The Levites rallied to him; three thousand died. This is the seventeenth of Tammuz, a fast day ever since.
How we know
On the chronology
Here the chronologies differ not by years but by a century. Seder Olam Rabbah places the Exodus in 1313 BCE. The prevailing academic date is the thirteenth century, the time of Ramesses II: its firm anchor is the stele of Pharaoh Merneptah of 1208 BCE, the first mention of Israel outside the Tanakh, where Israel is already in Canaan. A minority of scholars holds to the fifteenth century, reckoning by the plain count of I Kings 6:1 — four hundred and eighty years from the Exodus to Solomon's Temple. The timeline shows the prevailing dating.
Sources
Tanakh
- Devarim 9:7–21 — the same account in Moshe’s words
- Shemot 32 — the calf, the broken tablets, the intercession and the punishment
Chazal: Mishnah, Talmud, midrash, Zohar
- Taanit 4:6 — the seventeenth of Tammuz — the breaking of the tablets among the five calamities of that day
- Shabbat 89a — the miscounting of the forty days and the bier shown by Satan
- Berachot 32a — Moshe’s prayer: how he “would not let go” of the Almighty
Rishonim
- Rashi on Shemot 32:1 — boshesh — “he is late”: how the fatal error arose
Basis: stated in the Tanakh.
People and places
Levi · Moses · Aaron · Mount Sinai · Exodus · Yom Kippur · Tammuz · Avodah zarah—idolatry